Dear nonprofit leaders,
I have a question: How many people need to approve a fundraising email before you're allowed to send it?
The Development Director writes the appeal. Communications reviews it. The Executive Director has some feedback. A board member wants to weigh in on the messaging. Someone from Programs thinks the story needs more context. The Development Committee would like to discuss the ask amounts.
Then somebody suggests running it by the Board Chair.
Wonderful. We've assembled the United Nations to approve an email asking people for $50.
Three weeks later, the appeal is finally ready. The original fundraising opportunity has passed, the Development Director has rewritten the message six times, and half the people who provided feedback have forgotten what they were reviewing in the first place.
And somehow, we call this collaboration.
I've worked with enough nonprofit organizations to recognize this pattern. People genuinely want to contribute. They care about the mission, want fundraising communications to represent the organization well, and believe their perspectives will improve the final product.
Those are good intentions. But when every fundraising decision requires a committee, we create an organizational environment where everyone has an opinion and nobody has clear authority to act.
And that can become a serious problem for fundraising.
Collaboration Shouldn't Require Everybody's Permission
I am a HUGE advocate for building a thriving Culture of Philanthropy.
At Queer For Hire, we spend a significant amount of time helping organizations understand that fundraising is everybody’s business and it requires participation across leadership, staff, and the Board of Directors. Development needs access to program information, financial data, organizational priorities, community relationships, and the people who make the mission possible.
Fundraising should be informed by perspectives from across the organization. Program staff understand the communities being served. Finance understands financial realities and reporting requirements. Communications brings expertise in messaging and audience engagement. Executive leadership provides strategic direction. Board members contribute relationships, oversight, and organizational perspective.
All of that matters. But somewhere along the way, some nonprofits have interpreted shared responsibility to mean that everybody should participate in every decision. And that creates a mess.
Your Programs Director should absolutely help Development understand the impact of a new initiative. That doesn't necessarily mean they need to approve every donor communication referencing the program.
Your Finance Director should help establish revenue projections, campaign budgets, and gift processing procedures. That doesn't mean they need to review the subject line of your GivingTuesday email.
Your Board should help establish fundraising expectations, participate in philanthropy, and provide appropriate oversight. That doesn't mean the Development Committee needs to approve the language in every solicitation.
Collaboration works when people understand how their expertise contributes to a shared objective.
It becomes dysfunctional when participation turns into an unlimited opportunity to delay decisions.
A thriving Culture of Philanthropy requires shared participation AND clear decision-making authority.
We need both.
Your Development Director Was Hired to Make Fundraising Decisions
Let's talk about the professional fundraiser in the room.
Organizations hire Development Directors because they need someone with the expertise to build fundraising strategies, manage donor relationships, create campaigns, evaluate opportunities, and generate contributed revenue.
Then, in some organizations, they proceed to question or override nearly every professional decision that person makes.
The Development Director recommends a campaign timeline. Leadership wants to reconsider it.
They propose donor segmentation based on giving history and engagement. Someone thinks every donor should receive the same message.
They recommend a major gift cultivation strategy. A board member wants to send the prospect a solicitation immediately.
They develop a year-end appeal. Six people rewrite the opening paragraph because everyone has a different opinion about what sounds compelling.
At some point, we need to ask why the organization hired a fundraising professional if it isn't prepared to let them exercise professional judgment.
Of course, Development Directors should be accountable. Their recommendations should be informed by organizational priorities, financial realities, ethical standards, and the communities their organizations serve. They should welcome constructive feedback, collaborate with colleagues, and explain the reasoning behind their strategies.
And sometimes their recommendations will need to change. But professional accountability should come with professional authority. If someone is responsible for fundraising performance, they need reasonable control over the decisions that influence that performance. Otherwise, leadership is holding them accountable for outcomes while distributing the authority to make decisions across people who may have little fundraising expertise.
That's an organizational design problem. And it's one that can make even an excellent Development Director ineffective.
Your Board Is Supposed to Govern. Let Your Staff Manage.
Oh, this one is going to make some people uncomfortable.
Board members have important responsibilities. They provide governance, financial oversight, strategic direction, and accountability. They help ensure that the organization operates in alignment with its mission and fulfills its obligations.
They can also be tremendous fundraising partners.
But board involvement in fundraising should have boundaries.
A board member who introduces a major donor prospect is contributing something valuable. A board member who participates in stewardship, opens doors to corporate partners, or helps organize a peer-to-peer campaign is actively supporting fundraising.
A board member who insists on rewriting the Development Director's appeal because they personally dislike the phrase “invest in our mission” is doing something very different.
I've seen organizations where board members become unofficial supervisors of fundraising staff, providing detailed direction on everything from event planning to donor communications.
Sometimes this happens because the organization lacks clear governance boundaries. Sometimes an especially engaged board member has simply become accustomed to being involved in operational decisions. And sometimes leadership welcomes the additional input without considering how it affects staff authority.
Whatever the reason, the result can be deeply frustrating.
Board members should understand fundraising strategy, review performance, participate in resource development, and help leadership address significant risks or opportunities. But routine fundraising implementation belongs with the professionals responsible for managing it.
And if your Development Committee spends most of its time reviewing staff work rather than actively participating in fundraising, I have another blog you should read: Your Development Committee Should Have Something to Do.
Because I would much rather see a board member making a donor introduction than spending forty-five minutes debating the color of a donation button.
Consensus Can Become an Excuse for Avoiding Responsibility
Here's something I've noticed about organizations that rely heavily on committee decision-making.
Sometimes nobody wants to be the person who makes the final call.
A fundraising opportunity comes up, and leadership wants more perspectives before committing. A campaign needs approval, so the decision gets deferred until the next meeting. A donor engagement strategy raises questions, and everyone agrees that another conversation would be helpful.
Eventually, the organization has spent more time discussing the decision than it would have taken to implement it.
Consensus can be valuable, particularly when decisions affect organizational values, community trust, major financial commitments, or strategic direction. But requiring consensus for routine fundraising decisions creates unnecessary complexity.
It also makes accountability harder. If six people collectively approve a campaign, who is responsible when the timeline slips? If everyone has authority to request changes, who decides when the work is finished? If a fundraising opportunity is lost because approval took too long, who owns that decision?
Too often, the answer is nobody. And the Development Director is left explaining why the campaign didn't perform as expected.
This is why organizations need to distinguish between decisions that require consultation, decisions that require formal approval, and decisions that can be made by the person responsible for the work.
Those categories should be clear before an urgent decision arises.
A $250,000 fundraising initiative with significant financial or reputational implications may require executive and board involvement. A routine donor stewardship email probably doesn't.
The level of oversight should reflect the significance and risk of the decision.
When every decision receives the same approval process, organizations waste time on small decisions and lose the ability to focus attention on the ones that genuinely matter.
Sometimes the Problem Is That Nobody Knows Who Owns What
One of the first things I look for when helping organizations strengthen fundraising operations is clarity around roles and responsibilities.
Who develops the fundraising strategy? Who approves campaign budgets? Who owns donor communications? Who determines solicitation timing? Who is responsible for grant submissions? Who makes decisions about major gift prospects? Who can authorize changes when circumstances shift? And who needs to be consulted along the way?
These questions sound basic, but you'd be surprised how often the answers are unclear.
In some organizations, Development assumes Communications owns final messaging approval, while Communications assumes the Executive Director does. The Executive Director thinks the Development Committee should weigh in, and the Development Committee believes its job is to provide recommendations rather than approve anything.
Now four different groups are involved, and nobody knows whose decision it actually is. This is why I encourage organizations to establish clear ownership for major fundraising functions.
For example, Development might own campaign strategy, donor segmentation, solicitation recommendations, and fundraising timelines. Communications might own brand standards and collaborate on messaging and distribution. Programs might verify impact information and ensure that stories are accurate and ethically represented. Finance might approve financial assumptions and help establish gift processing procedures. Executive leadership might authorize major strategic changes or commitments beyond established budgets.
The exact structure will depend on the organization's size, staffing, and governance.
A small nonprofit with three employees will operate differently from an organization with a dedicated Development department, Communications team, and multiple program divisions.
But the principle is the same. Every important fundraising decision should have a clearly identified decision-maker. Other people can contribute expertise, provide feedback, and raise concerns. The organization should establish when that input is needed and how decisions will be finalized. And once a decision has been made through the agreed process, the team should be able to move forward.
Your Approval Process Might Be Costing You Money
Let's talk about the financial consequences.
Fundraising opportunities don't always arrive according to a convenient meeting schedule.
A major donor expresses interest in supporting a new initiative. A corporate partner wants to discuss a sponsorship. A foundation announces an unexpected funding opportunity. A community event creates an opening for donor engagement.
Sometimes these opportunities require quick decisions. If every response needs to move through multiple layers of approval, your organization may struggle to act while the opportunity is still available. And even when deadlines aren't urgent, excessive approval processes consume staff capacity.
Imagine a Development Director spending four hours preparing a campaign, then another six hours coordinating feedback, attending meetings, reconciling conflicting edits, and securing final approval.
That's ten hours of work for something that might have required five.
Multiply that across appeals, grant proposals, sponsorship materials, donor communications, events, and stewardship activities.
Now think about what those hours could have supported instead.
Donor cultivation meetings. Major gift prospecting. Stewardship calls. Corporate relationship development. Board fundraising activation. Data analysis. Strategic planning.
These are activities that contribute directly to fundraising capacity and future revenue.
Every additional approval step should have a purpose that justifies the time it requires.
And when organizations consistently delay fundraising decisions, they should consider the cumulative cost of those delays.
I'm not suggesting that speed should override thoughtful judgment. Poorly considered fundraising decisions can damage donor relationships, undermine community trust, and create financial or reputational risks.
But organizations should be capable of making responsible decisions efficiently. Efficiency is part of fundraising effectiveness.
Give People a Voice Without Giving Everyone a Veto
So how do we fix this?
Start by examining how fundraising decisions actually happen.
Choose a recent campaign, grant proposal, event, or donor communication and trace its approval process. Who was involved? Why were they involved? What expertise did they contribute? How many times was the work revised? Where did delays occur?
Then ask whether the process matched the importance of the decision.
You may discover that some approvals exist because of legitimate legal, financial, ethical, or reputational considerations. Those should remain.
You may also discover that other approvals exist because someone requested them three years ago and nobody ever questioned whether they were necessary.
Once you've identified the decision points, establish clear responsibilities.
Decide who owns routine fundraising implementation, who provides specialized input, and which decisions require executive or board approval.
Set reasonable review timelines. If Communications needs to review a campaign for brand consistency, define when that review happens. If Programs needs to verify impact information, establish a process for obtaining it before the appeal is drafted. If the Executive Director needs to approve major solicitations, identify which solicitations meet that threshold.
And create a process for resolving disagreements.
If Development and Communications have different recommendations, who makes the final decision? If a board member raises a concern about an approved campaign, how should that concern be addressed? If an urgent opportunity arises, who has authority to act?
These questions should have answers that everyone understands.
It's also worth recognizing that organizational size matters. A smaller nonprofit may have one person serving multiple roles, while a larger organization may need more formal approval procedures.
The goal is to create a process that supports good judgment, appropriate oversight, and timely implementation.
And please, don't create another standing committee to oversee the process of reducing committee approvals. I am begging you!
Trust Is an Organizational Responsibility
Ultimately, this conversation comes down to trust. Do nonprofit leaders trust the professionals they've hired to make decisions within their areas of expertise? Do staff trust that leadership will support them when they exercise reasonable judgment? Do board members trust that organizational management is capable of implementing the strategies they've approved? And does everyone understand how to raise concerns without bringing the entire organization to a standstill?
Trust doesn't eliminate accountability. It creates the conditions for accountability to function.
A Development Director should be able to explain their decisions, demonstrate progress, and accept responsibility for their work. Leadership should provide clear expectations, necessary resources, and appropriate oversight. Board members should focus on governance and meaningful fundraising participation.
And colleagues across the organization should contribute their knowledge without needing to control every decision.
This is particularly important for organizations trying to build a thriving Culture of Philanthropy.
When everyone understands their role, collaboration becomes easier. People know when their input is needed, how they can contribute, and who is responsible for moving the work forward.
That clarity makes fundraising more effective and helps reduce the frustration that comes from competing expectations.
Please Just Let the Fundraiser Send the Email
I want to end where we started.
Your Development Director has written a fundraising appeal. The message aligns with the organization's strategy. The program information has been verified. Communications has reviewed it for brand consistency. The solicitation is appropriate, the donation form works, and the campaign is ready to launch.
Do we really need another meeting?
Sometimes, the most supportive thing organizational leadership can do is establish clear expectations, provide the necessary information, and let the responsible professional do their job.
There will always be decisions that require broader discussion. Significant financial commitments, major strategic changes, sensitive community issues, and important organizational risks deserve thoughtful consideration.
But your nonprofit should be able to distinguish those decisions from the hundreds of routine choices required to implement a fundraising strategy.
Because every hour spent navigating unnecessary approvals is an hour that could have been invested in relationships, opportunities, and activities that support your mission.
So the next time a fundraising decision comes up, ask yourself: Who actually needs to be involved in this decision, and who has the authority to make it?
If the answer is everyone, you may have identified the problem.
Your Development Director has donors to cultivate, relationships to strengthen, campaigns to execute, and revenue to generate.
Please stop making them assemble a committee every time they need to do their job.
Sincerely,
Queers
Queer For Hire provides fundraising support to Queer nonprofits, LGBTQIA+ cultural competency to straight-led organizations and corporations, and individual coaching for Queer professionals.
Learn about our Fundraising Services <here> – we’ll lead or support your fundraising efforts, whether you need general support or want to focus on raising money from and for the LGBTQIA+ community.
Learn about our Fundraising Trainings <here> – we can coach your board, staff, and fundraising team on how to fundraise and how to engage LGBTQIA+ donors.
Learn about our other services <here> or our resources <here>.