Your Nonprofit Has a Fundraising Goal. Does It Have a Fundraising Budget?

Dear nonprofit budget makers,

I have a question for every nonprofit Executive Director and Board of Directors currently approving next year's budget: How much money do you expect your Development team to raise next year?

$500,000? $1 million? $5 million?

Wonderful. Ambitious. Love that for you.

Now here's my second question: How much money are you actually giving them to raise it?

And before you tell me about their salaries, I want to know about the actual fundraising budget. The money available for donor cultivation, stewardship, technology, professional development, prospect research, communications, travel, events, and all the other activities that make fundraising possible.

Because I've seen organizations set seven-figure fundraising goals while expecting their Development Director to accomplish everything with an outdated CRM, a Canva subscription, and a prayer.

Then, when revenue falls short, leadership starts asking whether the Development Director is performing.

Oh, we're going to have a conversation today.

The Fundraising Goal Is Always Bigger Than the Investment

Nonprofits have a fascinating relationship with fundraising expenses. We want more individual donors, but we're reluctant to invest in donor acquisition. We want major gifts, but there's no budget for cultivation. We want stronger donor retention, but stewardship gets whatever money is left after the annual gala. We want corporate sponsorships, but nobody has the capacity to build relationships with prospective partners.

And we want Development Directors who can strategically lead all of these efforts while simultaneously writing grants, managing events, maintaining the CRM, producing appeals, supervising volunteers, and attending seventeen meetings a week.

Somewhere along the way, we've convinced ourselves that fundraising should generate significant revenue without requiring significant investment.

Meanwhile, organizations routinely budget for program supplies, facilities, insurance, technology, transportation, and other operational expenses because we understand that delivering services costs money.

Fundraising also costs money.

It requires people, systems, materials, relationships, expertise, and time. Some of those investments produce revenue relatively quickly. Others take months or years to generate meaningful returns.

Yet when budgets get tight, Development expenses are often among the first things scrutinized.

That creates a particularly strange situation: the department responsible for generating much of the organization's contributed revenue is expected to operate with as little investment as possible.

And then we're surprised when fundraising capacity doesn't grow.

Your Development Director's Salary Is Not a Fundraising Strategy

Let's address something that comes up frequently when organizations discuss fundraising budgets.

“We already spend $90,000 on our Development Director.”

Okay. And?

That salary compensates a professional for their expertise, responsibilities, and labor. It's an important investment, and organizations absolutely need to account for personnel costs when evaluating fundraising expenses.

But hiring a fundraiser doesn't magically provide them with the infrastructure necessary to succeed.

Imagine hiring a chef, paying them a competitive salary, and then telling them there's no budget for ingredients, equipment, or kitchen staff.

You would have a very talented person standing in an empty kitchen.

And yet nonprofit organizations regularly hire experienced fundraising professionals and expect them to build sophisticated development programs without the resources those programs require.

A Development Director needs access to reliable donor information. They need systems for tracking relationships and revenue. They need communications support, opportunities to meet with donors, and enough administrative capacity to focus on work that requires their expertise.

Depending on the organization's size and strategy, they may also need prospect research tools, fundraising software, event support, professional development, or outside expertise.

The exact investment will vary. A small grassroots organization and a multimillion-dollar nonprofit will have very different needs.

But both need to understand what their fundraising goals will require.

If you're paying someone to raise money but refusing to fund the activities that make raising money possible, you've created a capacity problem.

And your Development Director is probably the person absorbing the consequences.

Stop Treating Every Fundraising Expense Like an Indulgence

One of the most frustrating habits in nonprofit budgeting is the tendency to evaluate fundraising expenses individually without considering what they're supposed to accomplish.

A Development Director requests funding to attend a conference. Leadership asks whether it's really necessary.

They want to upgrade the CRM. The organization decides the existing system is good enough, even though staff spend hours every month working around its limitations.

They propose a donor cultivation event. Someone asks whether the organization can avoid spending money by making it virtual.

They want to purchase prospect research tools. Leadership wonders whether they can just Google people instead.

They request additional administrative support. The answer is that everyone is already stretched thin.

Any one of these decisions might be reasonable. Organizations have limited resources, and spending should always be intentional.

But when the answer to every investment request is no, leadership is making a much larger decision about the organization's fundraising capacity.

And that decision rarely gets acknowledged.

Instead, the Development team is expected to find increasingly creative ways to accomplish the same goals with fewer resources.

There is a difference between being financially responsible and systematically underinvesting in the activities that generate revenue.

An expensive fundraising event that consistently loses money deserves scrutiny. So does software that nobody uses, a sponsorship strategy without clear prospects, or professional development that has little relevance to the organization's needs.

But a thoughtful investment in donor stewardship, data infrastructure, relationship-building, or fundraising expertise should be evaluated based on its contribution to the broader strategy.

The question should be: What are we trying to accomplish, and what investment will help us get there?

That's a much more useful conversation than automatically asking how little we can spend.

Fundraising Returns Don't Always Arrive in the Same Fiscal Year

Here's another challenge.

Nonprofit budgets are typically organized around annual financial performance. That makes sense. Organizations need to monitor revenue, expenses, cash flow, and financial sustainability.

But fundraising relationships don't necessarily develop according to your fiscal year.

A major gift prospect might require eighteen months of cultivation before making a significant commitment. A new monthly giving program may take time to acquire supporters and establish predictable recurring revenue. A corporate partnership might begin with a modest sponsorship and develop into a larger, multiyear relationship.

And donor retention is inherently a long-term measure. You need to keep people engaged over time to understand whether your stewardship investments are working.

When organizations expect every fundraising investment to produce an immediate financial return, they create incentives to prioritize activities that generate short-term revenue.

That can mean spending more time soliciting existing donors while neglecting acquisition. It can mean pursuing grants because applications have clear deadlines and potential award amounts, while donor cultivation gets pushed aside. It can mean investing heavily in one annual event because the revenue is familiar and relatively predictable.

Those decisions can help meet immediate financial needs.

But organizations also need to invest in the relationships and systems that will support future revenue.

This is where a thoughtful development budget should reflect both short-term cash flow requirements and longer-term fundraising objectives.

If you're launching a major giving program, what investment is needed during the first year to build the prospect pipeline? If you're expanding monthly giving, how will you support acquisition, conversion, and retention? If you're strengthening board fundraising, what resources are needed for training, coaching, stewardship, and accountability?

Some investments may not produce their full return until the following year or beyond.

That doesn't automatically make them unsuccessful.

It means leadership needs to understand what success should look like at different stages of implementation.

Your Fundraising Budget Should Reflect Your Development Strategy

At Queer For Hire, we approach sustainable fundraising through three interconnected areas: Development Strategy, Cash Flow Fundraising, and Culture of Philanthropy.

All three require investment, although the type and scale of that investment will vary.

Development Strategy establishes where the organization is going, how revenue streams fit together, what capacity exists, and what needs to be built. That work may require assessment, planning, data analysis, prospect research, and ongoing management.

Cash Flow Fundraising focuses on the activities generating contributed revenue. Annual giving, major gifts, monthly giving, corporate sponsorships, grants, events, and other revenue streams each have implementation costs.

Culture of Philanthropy creates the organizational conditions that support fundraising. Staff engagement, board activation, leadership participation, internal communication, and shared accountability all require time and attention.

An organization might have an ambitious strategy to diversify revenue through individual giving and corporate partnerships. But if its development budget allocates nearly every available dollar to grant writing and the annual gala, there's a disconnect.

The budget is reinforcing the existing fundraising model while the strategy calls for something different.

That disconnect is especially important for LGBTQIA+ nonprofits navigating changes in institutional funding.

Many organizations are recognizing the need to reduce dependence on a small number of foundations, government contracts, or other concentrated revenue sources.

Diversification is a worthwhile goal. But building new revenue streams requires resources.

You may need to improve donor data, develop a stronger Annual Fund, introduce recurring giving, identify major gift prospects, build corporate relationships, or create new opportunities for community philanthropy.

Those activities need to be supported financially and operationally.

If your development strategy calls for transformation, your fundraising budget needs to make that transformation possible.

Otherwise, you've created a wish list.

Let's Talk About the Cost of Doing Nothing

Nonprofit leaders are understandably concerned about spending money.

They have programs to deliver, staff to pay, communities to serve, and financial responsibilities to uphold.

I respect that.

But I also want leadership to consider the financial consequences of underinvestment.

What does it cost when donor records are incomplete, making stewardship and retention more difficult?

What does it cost when your Development Director spends ten hours every week manually producing reports because the CRM isn't configured properly?

What does it cost when major gift prospects receive little attention because everyone is busy preparing for the next event?

What does it cost when your board members have fundraising potential but no meaningful structure for participating?

And what does it cost when a talented Development Director leaves because the organization has consistently expected results without providing the resources to achieve them?

Those costs may never appear as individual line items in the budget.

But they are real.

Lost opportunities, inefficient systems, staff turnover, weak donor retention, and excessive dependence on a handful of funding sources can all undermine an organization's financial health.

Sometimes the decision to avoid spending $10,000 creates a much larger problem down the road.

That doesn't mean every proposed investment is worthwhile. It means doing nothing also has a cost, and nonprofit leaders should consider that cost when making financial decisions.

Your Board Should Be Asking Better Budget Questions

I would love to see nonprofit boards approach fundraising budgets with the same level of strategic attention they give to fundraising goals.

Instead of simply asking whether Development can raise another $200,000 next year, ask what it would take to make that growth realistic.

What additional activities would need to happen? Does the organization have enough qualified prospects? Is there sufficient staff capacity? What role will the Executive Director play? What responsibilities will board members assume?

What technology, communications, administrative support, or outside expertise might be necessary?

And perhaps most importantly, what assumptions are we making about the relationship between investment and revenue?

Boards should absolutely hold Development accountable for results. They should also help establish realistic expectations, understand the resources required, and participate in creating the conditions for success.

This is particularly important when organizations are approving budgets that depend on significant increases in contributed revenue.

If next year's operating budget assumes fundraising will grow by 30%, leadership should understand the strategy behind that projection.

Where is the additional revenue expected to come from? What activities will generate it? How much will those activities cost? What happens if revenue arrives later than anticipated?

And what will the organization do differently to achieve a result it hasn't achieved before?

Those conversations belong in the budget process.

They also belong in ongoing financial and development reporting, because the organization should be monitoring both revenue performance and the activities supporting that revenue.

So, What Should Actually Be in Your Fundraising Budget?

I'm not going to give you a universal percentage of revenue that every nonprofit should spend on fundraising.

Different revenue streams have different costs. Organizations have different levels of infrastructure, staffing, maturity, and financial capacity. A grassroots nonprofit building its first individual giving program will have different needs than an established organization with a mature major gifts operation.

A useful fundraising budget should be built around the organization's actual strategy.

Start with personnel. Who is responsible for fundraising, and how much of their time is available for different activities? What support do they need to perform their roles effectively?

Then examine the systems. Does your organization have the technology and data infrastructure necessary to manage donor relationships, process gifts, produce reports, and track fundraising performance?

Consider donor acquisition, cultivation, and stewardship. What will it cost to reach new supporters, strengthen existing relationships, and create meaningful opportunities for engagement?

Look at communications. What resources are required to produce effective appeals, donor updates, campaign materials, and impact communications?

Account for events, sponsorship fulfillment, professional development, prospect research, travel, and any specialized consulting support your strategy requires.

And remember that staff time is a resource, too.

A fundraising activity that appears inexpensive because it requires little direct spending may still consume hundreds of staff hours. Those hours have a cost, and they could potentially be invested elsewhere.

Once you've identified the necessary investments, connect them to specific fundraising objectives and realistic expectations.

You should be able to explain why an expense exists, what it supports, and how you'll evaluate whether it's contributing to the organization's fundraising health.

Some investments will be measured through immediate revenue. Others may be evaluated through donor retention, prospect development, staff efficiency, recurring revenue growth, or improved organizational capacity.

The goal is to make intentional decisions about how your organization invests in fundraising.

And if the resources simply aren't available to support every initiative in your development strategy, that's important information.

You may need to prioritize, phase in new activities, adjust revenue expectations, or reconsider how existing resources are allocated.

Those are responsible management decisions.

Pretending the organization can accomplish everything without additional capacity is where the trouble begins.

You Cannot Budget for a Miracle

I want to end with something that should be obvious but apparently needs repeating.

Your Development Director cannot raise money your organization hasn't created the capacity to pursue.

They can bring expertise, creativity, relationships, and determination. They can develop strategies, build donor pipelines, strengthen stewardship, and help establish a thriving Culture of Philanthropy.

But they cannot manufacture staff hours, functional systems, qualified prospects, organizational participation, or donor relationships out of thin air.

And when leadership sets ambitious fundraising goals without examining the investments necessary to achieve them, the organization is placing an enormous amount of responsibility on one person.

We need to get better at recognizing fundraising as an organizational function that deserves thoughtful investment.

That means Development leaders should be prepared to articulate what resources they need and why. Executive Directors should understand the connection between fundraising capacity and revenue expectations. Finance teams should help evaluate the costs, timing, and financial implications of different strategies. And boards should participate in making informed decisions about the organization's fundraising future.

Because the budget is where an organization makes its priorities tangible.

You can say you want stronger donor relationships. You can say you want more individual giving, better retention, diversified revenue, and a thriving Culture of Philanthropy.

But if you're unwilling to invest the time, money, and organizational capacity those priorities require, your fundraising goals are going to remain aspirational.

So as you prepare next year's budget, I want you to ask two questions.

How much money are we expecting Development to raise?

And what are we investing to make that possible?

If you can answer the first question immediately but have to scramble to answer the second, you've identified something worth addressing before the budget gets approved.

Because your fundraising goal deserves more than a number on a spreadsheet.

Give it a budget, too. 

Sincerely,

Queers

Queer For Hire provides fundraising support to Queer nonprofits, LGBTQIA+ cultural competency to straight-led organizations and corporations, and individual coaching for Queer professionals.

Learn about our Fundraising Services <here> – we’ll lead or support your fundraising efforts, whether you need general support or want to focus on raising money from and for the LGBTQIA+ community.

Learn about our Fundraising Trainings <here> – we can coach your board, staff, and fundraising team on how to fundraise and how to engage LGBTQIA+ donors.

Learn abotu our other services <here> or our resources <here>.

Previous
Previous

Stop Making Every Fundraising Decision in a Committee

Next
Next

Your Year-End Campaign Shouldn't Be Meeting Your Donors for the First Time