Dear nonprofit fundraisers,
I want you to think about the last time your organization received a major gift.
Maybe it was $5,000. Maybe it was $50,000. Maybe it was the largest individual contribution your nonprofit had ever received.
What happened next?
I'm guessing somebody picked up the phone. The Executive Director probably sent a personal thank-you. Perhaps a board member reached out. Maybe the donor received an invitation to lunch, a handwritten note, or an opportunity to meet with organizational leadership.
There might have even been a conversation about how to recognize the donor publicly.
Wonderful! That's exactly the kind of thoughtful stewardship I want organizations to practice.
Now I have another question.
What happened when somebody donated $25?
Did anyone call them? Did they receive anything beyond an automated receipt? Does anybody at your organization even know their name?
And before somebody tells me that you don't have time to personally call every $25 donor, I know. We're going to talk about that.
But first, we need to talk about how nonprofits decide who deserves to feel important.
Because somewhere along the way, we've built fundraising systems that treat our biggest donors like VIPs while everyone else gets an email template.
And I think we can do better.
The Major Donor Treatment
Let's establish something immediately: major donors deserve excellent stewardship.
They make significant financial commitments to organizations they believe in. Their generosity can expand programs, stabilize operations, create new opportunities, and help nonprofits respond to urgent community needs.
Major gift fundraising also requires substantial relationship-building. These donors often have complex philanthropic interests, want to understand the impact of their investments, and may appreciate opportunities to engage directly with organizational leadership.
There's nothing inherently wrong with offering individualized stewardship experiences.
At Queer For Hire, major giving is an important component of the sustainable fundraising strategies we help organizations develop. We encourage nonprofits to build meaningful relationships with donors, understand their philanthropic motivations, and create opportunities for continued engagement.
But I want us to examine what happens when our stewardship practices become almost entirely dependent on the size of someone's contribution.
The $10,000 donor gets a personal phone call. The $100 donor gets an automated acknowledgment.
The $25,000 donor gets invited to meet the Executive Director. The $25 monthly donor receives another email asking them to increase their gift.
The corporate sponsor gets recognized at the event. The community member who has donated every year for a decade might not even appear on the organization's stewardship calendar.
At what point did we decide that the amount someone gives determines how much they matter?
I understand the financial realities of fundraising. Organizations have limited resources, and major gift relationships require dedicated attention. Revenue concentration, donor capacity, and the potential for future giving are legitimate considerations when developing a fundraising strategy.
But the financial value of a gift and the value of a donor's relationship with your organization are two different things.
And when we confuse them, we risk overlooking some of the most important people in our philanthropic communities.
A $25 Gift Might Be Somebody's Major Gift
Here's something I wish more nonprofit leaders would remember.
You have absolutely no idea what it took for someone to make their donation.
For one person, $5,000 might represent a relatively comfortable philanthropic commitment. For another, $25 might require thoughtful budgeting and a genuine personal sacrifice.
Both people made a decision to support your mission.
And both deserve to know that their generosity matters.
This is particularly important for organizations serving communities that have historically experienced economic exclusion, discrimination, or barriers to wealth accumulation.
For LGBTQIA+ nonprofits, philanthropic participation often comes from people whose relationships with the mission are deeply personal. They may be giving because an organization helped them find community, access affirming services, navigate a difficult experience, or simply feel less alone.
Some supporters have significant financial resources. Others contribute what they can while navigating their own financial challenges.
If our stewardship systems recognize generosity primarily through dollar amounts, whose contributions are we overlooking?
I don't want an organization to look at a $10 monthly donor and see a $120 annual contribution.
I want them to see a person who has made a recurring commitment to their community.
Someone who has decided, month after month, that the mission deserves a place in their budget.
That's worth celebrating.
And frankly, if somebody has been giving you $10 every month for five years, I hope someone at your organization knows who they are.
Because that person has been showing up for you consistently.
Have you been showing up for them?
Loyalty Deserves Recognition, Too
Let's talk about the donor who has been giving $50 every December for the past twelve years.
They're never going to appear on your list of top twenty-five donors. They might not qualify for your major giving society. Their annual contribution may be too small to trigger a personal stewardship assignment in your CRM.
But they've supported your organization through leadership transitions, economic uncertainty, program changes, fundraising campaigns, and whatever else the last twelve years have thrown at you.
And they keep coming back.
That consistency matters.
Donor loyalty is one of the most valuable indicators of a healthy fundraising program. When people continue giving year after year, they're demonstrating trust in your organization and an ongoing commitment to its mission.
Yet many nonprofits spend enormous amounts of time identifying their largest donors while paying comparatively little attention to their longest-standing supporters.
I want organizations to start looking at donor relationships through more than one lens.
Yes, examine giving capacity and cumulative financial contributions. Those are important.
But also examine consecutive years of giving, monthly giving participation, volunteer engagement, advocacy, event attendance, referrals, and other forms of involvement.
Who has supported your organization for five years? Ten years? Twenty?
Who makes a gift every time you launch a campaign?
Who volunteers at your events, brings friends into your community, and then makes a modest donation on top of everything else?
Who consistently responds when you ask for help?
These are people who have demonstrated a meaningful commitment to your mission.
A donor's giving history tells a much richer story than the amount of their most recent gift.
And your stewardship strategy should reflect that.
Your Monthly Donors Are Already Acting Like VIPs
Can we please give monthly donors the attention they deserve?
Because I see organizations launch recurring giving programs, celebrate when somebody signs up, and then proceed to communicate with those donors almost exactly the same way they communicate with everyone else.
Sometimes it's even worse.
A monthly donor contributes automatically throughout the year, and the organization continues sending them the same urgent fundraising appeals without acknowledging that they're already providing ongoing support.
Now, monthly donors can absolutely make additional gifts. Many are happy to support special campaigns, events, or urgent needs.
But shouldn't our communications reflect the relationship we've already established?
If someone is giving your organization $25 every month, they're making a $300 annual commitment. More importantly, they're providing predictable revenue that helps support financial planning and organizational stability.
They're participating in your mission twelve months a year.
That deserves thoughtful stewardship.
Monthly donors should hear about the impact of their ongoing generosity. They should receive communications that acknowledge their recurring commitment. They should have opportunities to engage with the organization beyond being asked for another contribution.
And when you celebrate milestones, anniversaries, or program achievements, they should understand how their sustained support helped make those accomplishments possible.
One of the simplest things an organization can do is create a distinct stewardship experience for monthly donors.
It doesn't have to involve expensive gifts, exclusive events, or elaborate recognition programs.
A personalized anniversary message, an occasional update from leadership, or a thoughtful acknowledgment of their continued commitment can make a meaningful difference.
The goal is to help people feel connected to the work they're already sustaining.
Because monthly donors are doing exactly what nonprofit leaders say they want supporters to do.
They're making philanthropy a consistent practice.
Let's treat that commitment accordingly.
Stop Confusing Stewardship With Expensive Perks
Now, before somebody starts calculating the cost of sending personalized gifts to every donor, I need you to understand something.
Meaningful stewardship doesn't have to be expensive.
In fact, some of the most thoughtful donor experiences require very little money.
A personal thank-you from a staff member. A short video showing the impact of a program. A handwritten note from someone connected to the mission. An invitation to a community event. A phone call that exists solely to express appreciation.
These experiences can communicate genuine gratitude without requiring a substantial financial investment.
And sometimes the most meaningful thing you can offer a donor is simply the opportunity to understand what their contribution helped accomplish.
I've seen organizations spend considerable energy developing elaborate recognition packages for major donors while struggling to send timely acknowledgments to everyone else.
We need to examine those priorities.
Your stewardship program should have a foundation that every donor can experience.
Every gift should be acknowledged promptly and accurately. Every donor should receive meaningful information about organizational impact. Every supporter should have opportunities to remain connected to the mission.
From there, organizations can develop additional stewardship experiences based on donor interests, engagement, giving history, and relationship needs.
Some donors may appreciate public recognition. Others may prefer privacy. Some want opportunities to meet leadership or participate in programs. Others simply want to know that their contributions are being used responsibly.
And here's a radical thought.
You could actually ask your donors how they'd like to stay connected.
Imagine that.
Instead of assuming every major donor wants a gala invitation and every smaller donor wants another newsletter, we could start treating stewardship as an ongoing relationship.
Because that's what it should be.
Your CRM Might Be Reinforcing the Problem
I want you to open your donor database and think about how you identify your most important relationships.
If I asked you to pull a list of your top twenty-five donors, how would you do it?
For many organizations, the answer is simple: sort by giving amount.
That's a useful report. Every fundraising program should understand where its revenue comes from, who its major donors are, and how giving is distributed across its donor base.
But what happens if I ask for your twenty-five most loyal donors?
Or your longest-standing monthly supporters?
Or donors who have contributed consistently while also volunteering, attending events, or introducing new people to the organization?
Can your CRM identify those relationships?
And more importantly, are you doing anything with that information?
A healthy donor database should help organizations understand the breadth of their philanthropic community.
That means tracking more than transactions.
It means documenting meaningful interactions, communication preferences, engagement history, donor interests, and stewardship activities.
It means creating donor segments that reflect different types of relationships rather than relying exclusively on financial thresholds.
And it means using that information to make thoughtful decisions about how supporters are engaged.
For example, an organization might establish a stewardship initiative recognizing donors who have given for five consecutive years, regardless of amount.
It might create a special communication for supporters celebrating their first anniversary as monthly donors.
It might invite highly engaged volunteers who also contribute financially to a mission briefing.
Or it might identify donors who have participated in multiple campaigns and invite them into deeper conversations about the organization's future.
None of these strategies requires abandoning major gift fundraising.
They simply require us to recognize that philanthropic commitment takes many forms.
Your CRM should help you see those relationships.
And your fundraising strategy should help you strengthen them.
Everybody Can't Get a Personal Phone Call. I Know.
Let's address the capacity question.
Because every time I encourage organizations to expand stewardship beyond major donors, somebody inevitably says, “We don't have the staff capacity to personally steward everyone.”
Fair.
Most nonprofits are already navigating significant staffing and resource constraints. Development professionals are managing campaigns, grants, events, donor relationships, communications, reporting, and about seventeen other responsibilities that somehow ended up in their job descriptions.
I'm not suggesting that your Development Director should spend every afternoon calling hundreds of donors.
I'm suggesting that your organization should develop a stewardship strategy that reflects the full range of relationships sustaining your mission.
And that requires prioritization, planning, and shared responsibility.
Start by establishing a consistent stewardship experience for every donor. Timely acknowledgments, meaningful impact communications, and respectful engagement should be foundational expectations.
Then identify opportunities for additional personalization.
Perhaps your organization recognizes donors celebrating significant giving anniversaries. Maybe board members participate in thank-you calls during designated stewardship periods. Maybe program staff contribute stories and updates that help donors understand their impact.
Maybe your Executive Director records a quarterly message specifically for monthly supporters.
These activities can be incorporated into an annual fundraising calendar and distributed across the organization.
This is where a thriving Culture of Philanthropy becomes especially valuable.
Development shouldn't be the only department responsible for helping donors feel connected to the mission.
Leadership, staff, and board members can all contribute to meaningful stewardship when expectations are clear and activities are appropriately coordinated.
And no, that doesn't mean every staff member needs to become a fundraiser or personally solicit donations.
It means people across the organization can help demonstrate gratitude, communicate impact, and strengthen relationships.
The answer to limited capacity is a thoughtful stewardship system, supported by the people who make your mission possible.
And if your organization truly lacks the capacity to acknowledge and steward the donors it already has, that should be part of your fundraising budget conversation.
Because donor retention and relationship-building require investment, too.
Your Next Major Donor Might Already Be Giving You $25
There's another reason organizations should pay closer attention to supporters at every giving level.
You don't always know how a donor relationship will evolve.
Someone who begins with a $25 contribution might eventually become a monthly donor, volunteer, advocate, corporate partner, or major gift prospect.
Their financial circumstances may change. Their connection to the organization may deepen. They may introduce someone else who becomes an important philanthropic partner.
Or they may continue giving $25 every year for the next twenty years.
All of those outcomes have value.
But when organizations reserve meaningful engagement exclusively for donors who already meet major giving thresholds, they may miss opportunities to cultivate relationships that could grow over time.
Major gift fundraising is built through relationships, trust, and an understanding of what motivates people to give.
Those relationships have to begin somewhere.
And while prospect research and wealth indicators can help identify potential major donors, they don't tell us everything about someone's philanthropic interests, priorities, or willingness to engage.
A donor's current giving level shouldn't be the only factor determining whether we invest in getting to know them.
This is also why I encourage organizations to think about donor development as a continuum.
People may enter your philanthropic community through an event, a small contribution, volunteer service, a peer-to-peer campaign, or a personal connection to the mission.
Their engagement may deepen through stewardship, participation, education, and opportunities to contribute in ways that align with their interests and capacity.
Some will eventually make larger financial commitments. Others will become consistent supporters, ambassadors, volunteers, or community advocates. A sustainable fundraising strategy should create opportunities for those relationships to grow. And every stage deserves attention.
Let's Reconsider What VIP Means
I want to be clear that I'm not advocating for identical stewardship experiences for every donor.
That wouldn't be realistic, and it wouldn't necessarily be responsive to the different relationships people have with an organization.
Major donors may require individualized engagement. Monthly donors benefit from communications that recognize their ongoing commitments. Longtime supporters deserve acknowledgment of their loyalty. First-time donors should feel welcomed into the philanthropic community.
The goal is to develop stewardship practices that recognize different forms of commitment and help people feel genuinely valued.
And that requires nonprofit leaders to think beyond giving thresholds.
Who has been showing up for your organization year after year?
Who continues to give even when their contribution is modest?
Who shares your campaigns, introduces friends, volunteers their time, and advocates for your mission?
Who has supported you through difficult moments?
Who believes in what you're building?
Those people deserve to feel important.
They deserve to understand how their generosity contributes to the mission.
And they deserve to know that your organization sees them as more than a transaction in a database.
Because when we build philanthropic communities where people feel appreciated, informed, and connected, we create stronger foundations for long-term fundraising sustainability.
Your Donors Are People. Treat Them That Way.
Here's what I want nonprofit leaders to consider the next time they review their donor lists.
Look at your largest contributors. Celebrate them. Thank them. Continue building meaningful relationships with them.
Then keep scrolling.
Find the donor who has given $25 every year for the past decade.
Find the person who signed up to give $10 monthly during your last campaign.
Find the supporter who volunteers at every event and makes a contribution whenever they can.
Find the first-time donor who took a chance on your organization because something about your mission resonated with them.
Now ask yourself whether your stewardship strategy makes those people feel like valued members of your philanthropic community.
If the answer is no, you've got some work to do.
And I would encourage you to start before your next fundraising campaign.
Because those supporters are already demonstrating their commitment to your organization.
You have an opportunity to demonstrate yours in return.
Your biggest donors deserve to feel like VIPs.
So do the people who've been showing up for your mission with $10, $25, or $100 at a time.
Let's build fundraising cultures that recognize generosity, loyalty, and community commitment in all their forms.
Because every donor deserves to know that they matter.
And every donor deserves more than an automated receipt. 🌈
Sincerely,
Queers
Queer For Hire provides fundraising support to Queer nonprofits, LGBTQIA+ cultural competency to straight-led organizations and corporations, and individual coaching for Queer professionals.
Learn about our Fundraising Services <here> – we’ll lead or support your fundraising efforts, whether you need general support or want to focus on raising money from and for the LGBTQIA+ community.
Learn about our Fundraising Trainings <here> – we can coach your board, staff, and fundraising team on how to fundraise and how to engage LGBTQIA+ donors.
Learn about our other services <here> or our resources <here>.